VOICES — 'Searching for America's Sea Monster'

(EDITOR’S NOTE — 1120 Press is thrilled to publish the following story by veteran journalist Christopher Mele, a senior staff editor at The New York Times. “Searching for America’s Sea Monster” is the fifth installment in our “VOICES” series and follows researcher Katy Elizabeth — seen in the photos in the slider below — as she searches for Champ, America’s very own Loch Ness monster long believed to be lurking in the depths of Lake Champlain. We thank Chris for allowing 1120 Press to run his piece, which was initially published by About Men Radio at aboutmenshow.com.)


AS A KID I was captivated by the mysteries of UFOs, Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster,

ghosts and other paranormal doings.


I grew up watching the television series “In Search of…” hosted by Leonard Nimoy and read whatever books I could find about unexplained phenomena.

During free reading time in 7th grade, I was the nerd always with a book about UFOs, with titles such as “Project Blue Book” (named after the Air Force’s investigation into unidentified flying objects) or “Chariots of the Gods.”


Yeah, I was some sort of geek — a desk-bound adventurer.

My interest in those topics waned as I took on the responsibilities of career, family and the other trappings of adulthood. (However, I was a HUGE fan of the television series “The X-Files.”)

But somewhere deep down there remained that childlike spark of curiosity and wonder about things that do not fit our orderly understanding of the world. And when I read a Facebook post by reporter Lohr McKinstry about how he was donating a trove of his articles about Champ — the often-reported, sometimes-documented but never-authenticated mystery creature of Lake Champlain, known as the Loch Ness Monster of North America — that spark was fanned into a flame.

Lohr’s post led me to Katy Elizabeth, a leading Champ researcher to whom Lohr’s archive was donated and the founder of Champ Search, which is dedicated to proving the existence of — and protecting — Champ.

From my time working with Lohr at The Press-Republican — the daily newspaper in Plattsburgh, a small Northern New York city that sits along Lake Champlain — I was aware of the legend. Sightings of Champ stretch back centuries to when Indian tribes populated the area and continue to present day.


Some early accounts described Champ as a serpent more than 100 feet long, though Elizabeth believes it might be an amphibian/reptile hybrid that is between 15 and 30 feet long, with knobs on its back, a long, slender snake-like neck and a head shaped like a horse.


Skeptics believe the sightings can be attributed to gar, sturgeon, schools of fish or even logs.

Me? I was just excited to shadow Elizabeth.

Over the years I’ve grown to appreciate people who see the world differently. They open up new horizons. Plus, I have all the admiration and respect for anyone who is passionate about their work.

My day with Elizabeth was like going on a ghost hunt with all the spectrometers and other paranormal-measuring equipment, except, instead of looking for spirits in the basement of an abandoned hotel, I’d be outdoors on the shore of Lake Champlain.

Elizabeth — who is known among locals as the “Champ Lady” or the “Lake Monster Queen” — got turned onto Champ when she was 7. She was watching an episode of “Unsolved Mysteries,” which featured an episode about the creature.

She got hooked and has been ever since.

Elizabeth will get up before sunrise and spend two to four hours staking out the lake and then return at sunset, the theory being that Champ is nocturnal.

The trunk of her car is filled with hard plastic containers with hydrophones that include a recorder and underwater microphone, binoculars, camera and tripod.

“You are not going to see something every day, but when you do, it’s an amazing experience,” she said, adding that patience and staying open to possibilities are critical.

Elizabeth, who grew up in Rhode Island near water, said she is a trained observer of lakes and seas and can readily distinguish logs, fish and boats from other objects on the water’s surface that are not readily explained.

Some of the things she told me about Champ were a surprise.


For instance, though “Champ” is often referred to in the singular, it really is “Champs,” as in a whole school of them.

She described the creatures as “a very tough species of animals” given how they have survived the sewage and other pollution that has gone into the lake over the years.

I was also surprised to learn there have been reported sightings of Champ on land.

Elizabeth regularly scours the shoreline searching for teeth, bones or other physical traces of Champ. In one case she found a bone of an ancient bison, a conclusion she said was backed up by a natural history museum in Ohio that examined the relic.

“It’s really cool to find stuff like that to remind you how ancient this area is,” she said.

As for the dearth of physical evidence of Champ, such as scat, a skeleton or carcass, Elizabeth is quick to ask: “How many times do you find a dead turtle? You think about whales and dolphins. How many times do you see a carcass of these animals?”

She added some species know when their death is imminent and seek hidden places to die. And with Lake Champlain being 120 miles long, there are a lot of places to hide.

Elizabeth herself has had more than a dozen encounters with Champ, garnering her five different videos and four or five audio recordings. Some of the sounds might be territorial calls, she said.

She attributes her extraordinary number of sightings to a heightened sensitivity to paranormal elements.

“I am not Ms. Cleo,” she said, referring to the psychic best known for her television commercials pitching a psychic pay-per-call service.


“I pick up on things.”

While some “armchair researchers” will either merely talk about the search for Champ or put in a perfunctory effort, Elizabeth said she is dedicated full time to finding proof of its existence.

But her work will not stop there.

Protecting the creature is vital, she said. “People think that once Champ is discovered, that’s the end, but it’s really the beginning.”

Such a discovery would open up study to 'tagging' Champ, similar to sharks or whales and learning more about its behaviors and characteristics.

“I think the most important thing for people who are skeptical is to keep an open mind,” she said. “To think we are the only beings on this planet is selfish.”


On the day of my visit, we were at Arnold Bay on the Vermont side, looking across the lake at Westport and Port Henry in New York. Apart from a father and daughter fishing, I didn’t see any activity on the lake.

I’m a skeptic by nature (and training) but it’s difficult, after talking at length to Elizabeth and hearing her passion and enthusiasm for her work, not to discount the possibility that something unexplained lurks beneath the surface in Lake Champlain.


I want to believe…